Northstar IT & Cyber Advisory
  • About
  • Services
    • Fractional IT & Cyber Director
    • Board-Level IT & Cyber Risk Review
    • AI Readiness & Advisory
    • Service Pages
    • Cyber Insurance Readiness
    • Fractional vs Full-Time IT Director
  • How We Help
    • Cyber Incident Response
    • M&A IT Due Diligence
    • Cyber Essentials
    • IT Spend Review
    • Fast Growth IT
    • Compliance Advisory
    • IT Supplier Failure
    • AI Strategy & Readiness
    • AI Governance & Policy
    • See all nine situations →
    • ⭐ Free Guide: Ten Questions
    • ⭐ Free Checklist: SME Cyber Risk
    • ⭐ Free Guide: AI Risk
  • Industries
    • Professional Services
    • Financial Services
    • Legal
    • Property
    • Distribution
    • Manufacturing
    • Locations
    • London
    • Kent
    • Essex
    • Sussex
    • Surrey
    • South East
    • Don’t see your sector? Get in touch →
  • Insights
  • FAQs
  • Get in Touch
Northstar IT & Cyber Advisory
  • About
  • Services
  • Fractional IT & Cyber Director
  • Board-Level IT & Cyber Risk Review
  • AI Readiness & Advisory
  • Cyber Insurance Readiness
  • Fractional vs Full-Time IT Director
  • How We Help
  • Cyber Incident Response
  • M&A IT Due Diligence
  • Cyber Essentials
  • IT Spend Review
  • Fast Growth IT
  • Compliance Advisory
  • IT Supplier Failure
  • AI Strategy & Readiness
  • AI Governance & Policy
  • See all nine situations →
  • Free Guide: Ten Questions
  • Free Checklist: SME Cyber Risk
  • Free Guide: AI Risk
  • Industries
  • Professional Services
  • Financial Services
  • Legal
  • Property
  • Distribution
  • Manufacturing
  • Locations
  • London
  • Kent
  • Essex
  • Sussex
  • Surrey
  • South East
  • Don’t see your sector? Get in touch →
  • Insights
  • FAQs
Get in Touch
cs@northstaritadvisory.com 0333 577 1714

Five years ago, supplier data security questionnaires were largely the preserve of large financial institutions, government departments and healthcare organisations. If you were not in their supply chain, you were unlikely to receive one.

That has changed significantly. The questionnaires have followed a clear pattern of trickling down through supply chains, from regulated enterprise to mid-market, from mid-market to SME supplier. The businesses receiving them today are not fundamentally different from the businesses that were not receiving them three years ago. The businesses sending them have simply extended their requirements further down the chain.

What these questionnaires are actually asking

The content of supplier security questionnaires varies but the majority cover a consistent set of areas. Understanding what is being asked, and why, helps both in preparing answers and in understanding what genuinely needs to be in place.

**Cyber security controls**

Questions about what technical security controls are in place. Firewall configuration, endpoint protection, patch management practices, email security, multi-factor authentication. These questions are assessing whether your business has implemented the basics, roughly equivalent to what Cyber Essentials certification tests.

**Data protection practices**

Questions about how personal data is handled. What data you process, on what legal basis, how it is protected, who has access, how long it is retained and what your breach response process looks like. These questions are assessing UK GDPR compliance.

**Access management**

Questions about how user access is managed. How accounts are provisioned and deprovisioned, how administrator access is controlled, whether multi-factor authentication is in place for remote access and privileged accounts.

**Business continuity**

Questions about resilience. Whether you have a tested backup and recovery process, whether you have a business continuity plan, what your recovery time objectives are.

**Third-party risk**

Questions about your own supply chain. What suppliers have access to your systems or data, what due diligence you have conducted on them, whether Data Processing Agreements are in place.

**Certifications and evidence**

Many questionnaires now ask specifically for Cyber Essentials certification, ISO 27001 certification, or other third-party evidence of security practices. The move from self-attestation to third-party evidence is one of the most significant shifts in supplier security requirements over the past two years.

Why this is happening

The organisations sending these questionnaires have learned, often from painful experience, that their supply chain represents a significant attack surface. A large enterprise with sophisticated security controls can still be compromised through a smaller, less well-protected supplier that has privileged access to their systems or data.

The regulatory environment reinforces this. UK GDPR places explicit obligations on data controllers regarding the security practices of their processors. Enterprise legal and compliance teams are increasingly requiring evidence of supplier security as a contractual and regulatory necessity rather than a nice-to-have.

What happens if you cannot answer

In the short term, the questionnaire gets escalated within the client’s procurement or security team. You may be given an opportunity to remediate specific gaps. In some cases there is flexibility on timeline.

In the longer term, businesses that consistently cannot answer these questionnaires satisfactorily are quietly removed from preferred supplier lists or excluded from tender processes before they reach the questionnaire stage. This happens without fanfare, you simply stop being considered.

How to prepare

The good news is that the controls being asked about are not exotic or expensive. They are broadly equivalent to what Cyber Essentials certification tests, five core technical controls that most businesses are closer to implementing than they realise.

The preparation has three elements. First, understand what your current position actually is, not what you assume it is, but what an honest assessment reveals. Second, close the gaps that matter most, prioritised by what is most commonly asked for rather than what is most technically complex. Third, document what you have in place so you can evidence it clearly when asked.

Northstar’s IT and Cyber Risk Review is designed specifically to give you an honest picture of where you stand against these requirements, and what proportionate action looks like for a business of your size.

The conversation about independent IT leadership in an SME almost always starts with cost. How much does a fractional IT director cost? Is it justified for a business of our size? What would we actually get for the money?

These are reasonable questions. But they are only half the equation. The other half, the cost of not having adequate IT leadership is rarely calculated with the same rigour. When it is, the case for independent oversight becomes significantly clearer.

What independent IT leadership actually costs

A fractional IT director engagement for a UK SME typically involves one to three days of senior advisory time per month. At market rates for genuinely senior, experienced IT leadership, not a junior consultant operating under a senior title, this represents a meaningful but proportionate investment.

The cost varies based on the complexity of the IT environment, the number of suppliers being managed, the frequency of board reporting required and whether the engagement includes specific project work alongside ongoing oversight.

For most SMEs, the annual cost of a well-structured fractional IT director engagement is significantly less than the fully-loaded cost of a single month of a full-time IT Director hire.

What poor IT governance actually costs

This is the calculation most businesses have not done. The costs of inadequate IT governance are real, recurring and typically much larger than the cost of the advisory that would have prevented them. They fall into several categories.

*Overspend on IT

As we have discussed elsewhere, IT spend without independent oversight typically drifts upward by 10 to 20 percent per year above what a well-managed IT cost base would look like. For a business spending £60,000 per year on IT, that is £6,000 to £12,000 per year in recoverable waste. Over three years without independent oversight, that accumulates to between £18,000 and £36,000.

*Suboptimal MSP performance

An MSP operating without independent client-side oversight delivers less than one operating under proper accountability. This is not a judgement, it is a commercial reality. The cost of suboptimal IT performance is harder to quantify but it manifests as lost productivity, slower resolution of issues, delayed projects and technology that is not fit for purpose.

*Cyber incident costs

The average cost of a cyber incident for a UK SME including remediation, lost productivity, potential regulatory fines and reputational damage, runs into tens of thousands of pounds at minimum and can significantly exceed that. Many of the controls that prevent or mitigate incidents, patch management, access control, backup testing, staff awareness are governance matters that independent IT oversight ensures are in place.

*Failed compliance

A business that loses a contract because it cannot evidence Cyber Essentials certification, or that faces ICO action following a data breach that was preventable, or that has a cyber insurance claim declined because its security practices did not meet policy conditions, each of these represents a cost that dwarfs the advisory that would have prevented it.

*Management time

IT issues that should be handled operationally consuming founder or MD time is a cost that rarely appears in any calculation but is consistently significant. Senior leadership time spent managing IT problems, mediating supplier disputes or trying to understand what their MSP is telling them is time not spent on the things that grow the business.

The actual calculation

Take your current annual IT spend. Apply a conservative 10 percent waste factor. Add a modest estimate for the management time currently consumed by IT issues. Add a probability-weighted estimate of the cost of a significant cyber incident. Add the commercial value of any contract opportunities that require Cyber Essentials or security evidence you cannot currently provide.

For most SMEs, that number is significantly larger than the cost of independent IT oversight. The question is not whether independent IT leadership costs money. It is whether the cost of not having it is larger – which, in almost every case, it is.

The managed service provider contract renewal is one of the most consistently mismanaged commercial moments in SME IT management. Most businesses treat it as an administrative formality, a document to sign so that service continues uninterrupted. Suppliers know this and price accordingly.

The renewal is not an administrative formality. It is a commercial negotiation. And approached correctly, it is one of the highest-leverage opportunities a business has to improve both the cost and the quality of its IT service relationship.

Why the renewal moment matters

At the point of renewal, the supplier wants something from you. They want another term of contracted revenue. This gives you leverage, leverage that diminishes significantly once the contract is signed.

Before renewal, you have options. You can negotiate terms. You can benchmark pricing. You can require service improvements as a condition of renewal. You can credibly consider alternatives. After renewal, the switching costs rise again and the supplier’s incentive to respond to your concerns diminishes.

Most businesses do not use this leverage because they do not recognise they have it, or because they leave the renewal too late to have any meaningful alternative.

The renewal playbook

**Step 1 – Know your notice period**

Most MSP contracts include an automatic renewal clause with a notice period, typically between 30 and 90 days before the contract end date. If you miss this window, you are committed to another term at existing terms and pricing regardless of how the service has performed.

Mark the notice deadline in your calendar the moment you sign any IT contract. Set a reminder three months before that date so you have time to prepare.

**Step 2 – Conduct a service review before entering negotiations**

Before you approach the supplier about renewal, conduct an honest assessment of the service delivered during the current term. This means reviewing response times against SLA commitments, documenting recurring issues that were not resolved satisfactorily, identifying projects that were committed to but not delivered, and assessing whether the scope of services still reflects how the business operates.

This assessment gives you the factual basis for a negotiation rather than a vague feeling that things could be better.

**Step 3 – Benchmark the market**

You do not need to go to full tender to understand whether your current pricing is competitive. A conversation with one or two alternative providers about indicative pricing for equivalent services gives you a market reference point.

This serves two purposes. It tells you whether you are paying above market rates. And it gives you credible alternatives that you can reference in the negotiation, which changes the dynamic significantly.

**Step 4 – Prepare your opening position**

Enter the renewal negotiation knowing what you want:

– The price you want to pay, based on your market benchmarking

– The service improvements you require, based on your service review

– The contract terms you want to change, notice periods, SLA definitions, exit provisions

– The scope adjustments that reflect how the business currently operates

**Step 5 – Have the conversation at the right level**

Renewal negotiations should happen at a senior level, with the supplier’s account director or managing director, not with your day-to-day account manager. The account manager typically has limited commercial authority and a strong incentive to present the renewal as straightforward.

**Step 6 – Be willing to walk away**

The single most powerful position in any negotiation is genuine willingness to pursue an alternative. If the supplier believes you will renew regardless, your leverage is minimal. If they believe you have credible alternatives and are genuinely prepared to use them, the negotiation proceeds very differently.

This does not mean switching suppliers is always the right outcome. In many cases a well-managed renewal produces the improved terms and service commitments that make the existing relationship worth continuing. But that outcome is far more likely when the supplier knows the alternative is real.

What good renewal terms look like

A well-negotiated MSP renewal typically includes:

– Pricing at or below current market rates, with a defined cap on annual increases

– Clearly defined SLAs with financial remedies for breach

– A structured quarterly service review process built into the contract

– Notice provisions that give the business reasonable flexibility

– Exit provisions that ensure full cooperation with any transition, including data return and handover support

– A scope of services that accurately reflects current requirements

None of these are unreasonable asks. They are standard commercial protections that most businesses fail to secure because they do not approach renewal as a negotiation.

When most people think about cyber attacks on businesses, they think about ransomware. Systems locked, data encrypted, a demand for payment. It is dramatic, visible and well-covered in the press.

Business email compromise is quieter, less dramatic and measured by financial loss, more costly. It is also, in many ways, better suited to targeting small and medium-sized businesses than large enterprises.

What business email compromise actually is

Business email compromise, or BEC, is a category of fraud in which an attacker manipulates email communications to deceive someone in a business into making a payment, revealing credentials or taking some other action that serves the attacker’s interests.

The most common variants are:

Payment diversion – An attacker intercepts or spoofs email communications between a business and one of its suppliers. They send an email appearing to come from the supplier, informing the business that the supplier’s bank details have changed and requesting that future payments be made to a new account. The business updates their records and makes the next payment to the attacker’s account. By the time the fraud is discovered, the money is gone.

Invoice fraud – Similar to payment diversion but typically initiated by impersonating the supplier rather than intercepting communications. The attacker sends a convincing fake invoice, often for a plausible amount, from an email address that closely resembles the supplier’s real address.

CEO fraud – An attacker impersonates a senior executive, typically the MD or CEO and sends an urgent email to the finance team requesting an immediate payment. The urgency and apparent seniority of the request bypasses normal authorisation procedures.

Credential harvesting – A more technically sophisticated variant in which the attacker gains access to a legitimate email account, often through phishing and monitors communications over weeks or months before identifying and exploiting a payment opportunity.

Why BEC is particularly dangerous for SMEs

Large organisations typically have multi-person payment authorisation processes, dedicated finance teams with established verification procedures, and fraud detection systems that flag unusual payment requests. These controls significantly reduce the effectiveness of BEC attacks.

SMEs often have none of these. Payment authorisation may rest with a single person. Supplier relationships are managed informally. Verification procedures calling the supplier to confirm changed bank details exist in principle but are not consistently followed under time pressure.

The attacker knows this. BEC attacks are frequently targeted specifically at smaller businesses for exactly this reason.

The financial impact

UK Finance and Action Fraud consistently report BEC as one of the most financially damaging categories of fraud for UK businesses. Unlike ransomware, where recovery is sometimes possible, BEC fraud typically results in immediate and largely irrecoverable financial loss. Banks have limited ability to recall payments once they have been processed, particularly where the funds have been moved quickly through multiple accounts.

The average loss per incident for SMEs is significant, typically ranging from tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of pounds depending on the nature of the business and the payment intercepted.

The defences that actually work

Verification by a different channel – Any request to change supplier payment details should be verified by calling the supplier on a known number, not a number provided in the email, before the change is made. This single control eliminates the majority of payment diversion fraud.

Payment authorisation controls – No single person should be able to authorise and execute a significant payment without a second person confirming. This applies particularly to payments above a defined threshold and to any payment to a new or recently changed payee.

Email security configuration – Properly configured email security including SPF, DKIM and DMARC records makes it significantly harder for attackers to spoof your domain or your suppliers’ domains. Many SMEs have not checked whether these are correctly configured.

Staff awareness – The most important defence is people who know what to look for and feel empowered to question an unusual request, even when it appears to come from a senior person. A culture where anyone can say “this looks odd, can I verify before I act?” is genuinely protective. **Cyber insurance that covers BEC.** Not all cyber insurance policies cover business email compromise. Some treat it as fraud rather than a cyber incident and exclude it. This is worth checking with your broker before you need to make a claim.

Cyber Essentials is the UK government-backed cybersecurity certification scheme that more and more businesses are being asked to demonstrate. If you have been asked about it by a client, an insurer, or a procurement team, or if you have heard the term and wondered what it actually involves, this post is for you.

What Cyber Essentials is

Cyber Essentials is a certification scheme developed by the National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) in partnership with industry. It defines a set of five basic technical controls that, when properly implemented, protect organisations against the most common cyber attacks.

The scheme was introduced in 2014, initially as a requirement for businesses supplying certain government contracts. It has since become a much broader benchmark – used by insurers, enterprise procurement teams, and regulated sector clients as a baseline indicator of cyber hygiene.

There are two levels of certification:

**Cyber Essentials** – a self-assessment questionnaire, independently verified by an accredited certification body. You answer a series of questions about your IT environment and security controls. A qualified assessor reviews your answers and, if they meet the required standard, issues the certification.

**Cyber Essentials Plus** – includes everything in the standard certification, plus an independent technical verification carried out by an assessor who tests your systems directly. This provides a higher level of assurance and is increasingly required for public sector contracts and regulated sector supply chains.

The five controls

The Cyber Essentials framework is built around five technical controls:

1. Firewalls – a boundary firewall must be in place to protect your internet connection. For cloud-based businesses, this extends to software firewalls on individual devices.

2. Secure configuration – devices and software must be configured securely. Default passwords must be changed. Unnecessary software and services must be disabled or removed.

3. User access control – user accounts must have only the access they need for their role. Administrator privileges must be limited to those who genuinely require them. Accounts must be removed or disabled promptly when employees leave.

4. Malware protection – protection against malicious software must be in place on all devices. This includes up-to-date antivirus or modern endpoint detection and response (EDR) solutions.

5. Patch management – software, operating systems and firmware must be kept up to date. Known vulnerabilities must be patched within 14 days of a patch becoming available.

These are not complex or expensive controls. Most businesses are at least partially compliant already. The certification process tests whether the controls are properly implemented, consistently applied, and accurately documented.

Who needs it and why

Cyber Essentials was originally associated primarily with government contracts – the Cabinet Office mandated it for suppliers handling certain types of government data from 2014. That requirement has been progressively extended and today covers the majority of central government contracts involving sensitive data or network connectivity.

Beyond government procurement, the drivers are now broader:

Cyber insurance – insurers are increasingly using Cyber Essentials as a rating factor. Businesses with certification typically attract lower premiums and face fewer exclusions. Some insurers are beginning to require it for new policies.

Enterprise supply chain – large organisations are extending their security requirements to suppliers. If you supply a financial services firm, a healthcare provider, or a large retailer, you may find Cyber Essentials appearing in their supplier questionnaires or as a contractual requirement.

Client confidence – for professional services businesses, certification provides a straightforward way to demonstrate that client data is being handled responsibly.

Regulatory environment – while Cyber Essentials is not currently a legal requirement for most UK businesses, it aligns closely with the technical controls expected under UK GDPR and sector-specific regulations such as those applying to financial services and healthcare.

How long does it take and what does it cost?

For most SMEs, achieving Cyber Essentials from a standing start takes between four and twelve weeks, depending on how compliant your current IT environment is.

The cost of the certification itself is relatively modest – typically between £300 and £500 for the standard certification, with additional costs for CE+ depending on the size and complexity of your environment. The main variable is the cost of closing any gaps identified during the assessment process – which may require IT changes that your MSP will charge for.

This is one of the reasons working with an independent advisor before starting the certification process is valuable – understanding what gaps exist, what they will cost to close, and whether the remediation approach your MSP proposes is proportionate.

CE vs CE+: which do you need?

For most SMEs, the standard Cyber Essentials certification is sufficient. It demonstrates compliance with the five core controls, satisfies the majority of procurement requirements, and provides a meaningful baseline of cyber hygiene.

Cyber Essentials Plus is appropriate if:

– You supply central government contracts that specifically require it

– You handle particularly sensitive data – healthcare, financial, or defence-related

– Your clients are large enterprises with mature supply chain security requirements

– You want to provide the highest level of assurance to the market

If you are unsure which level is right for your business, the answer usually depends on what you are being asked to demonstrate and by whom. That is a question an independent advisor can help you answer in about fifteen minutes.

Getting started

If you are considering Cyber Essentials and want to understand where your business currently stands before committing to the assessment process, a readiness review is the sensible first step. It tells you what the gaps are, what they will cost to close, and what the assessment process will involve for a business with your particular IT environment. Northstar offers Cyber Essentials readiness assessments as part of its IT and Cyber Risk Review service.

The IT supplier relationship is one of the most commercially significant relationships in most SMEs – and one of the least well managed.

Not because business owners are careless. But because the relationship starts in a position of imbalance – the supplier understands the technology, and the client does not – and that imbalance tends to compound over time.

How the dynamic typically develops

Most SME IT supplier relationships follow a recognisable pattern.

The business selects a managed service provider, usually on the basis of a recommendation or a competitive tender. The relationship starts well. Issues are resolved promptly. The supplier is responsive. The MD feels confident.

Over time, the relationship matures into something more comfortable for the supplier than the client. The business becomes dependent on systems and processes the supplier has built and configured. Switching costs, real and perceived, rise. The supplier knows this.

Service levels drift. Response times lengthen. Promised projects are perpetually deprioritised. The business raises issues informally but never formally. The supplier absorbs the feedback without meaningful change.

At renewal, the supplier presents a proposal for the next term at an increased rate. The business, aware of the switching costs and the relationship it has built, accepts, often without benchmarking against alternatives or properly challenging the terms.

This pattern is not unique to IT. But it is particularly pronounced in IT, because the technical asymmetry makes it hard for clients to know whether they are getting good service or not.

What good supplier management looks like

Good IT supplier management is not adversarial. It is professional. It treats the supplier relationship as a commercial relationship, with clear expectations, regular performance reviews, and consequences for underperformance, while maintaining a constructive working relationship.

The key elements are:

A clear contract – one that defines the scope of services, the service level commitments, the process for raising and resolving issues, and the terms for exit. Many SMEs are operating on contracts that are vague on all of these points. Vague contracts favour the supplier.

Regular service reviews – a formal meeting, at least quarterly, where performance against agreed metrics is reviewed, issues are raised and tracked, and the relationship is assessed. Not an informal catch-up – a structured review with an agenda and actions.

Performance metrics that matter – not just “are the tickets being resolved” but “what is the resolution time against SLA, what issues are recurring, and what is being done about them?”

Benchmark awareness – a sense of whether you are paying market rates for the services you receive. You do not need to go to tender every year, but you should know whether your costs are broadly in line with alternatives.

An escalation path – when issues are not being resolved at the account level, there should be a clear process for escalating to senior management within the supplier. Many SMEs do not know who their senior contact at the MSP is.

Contract renewal discipline – treating renewal as a commercial negotiation, not an administrative formality. Reviewing the scope, benchmarking the price, and if necessary, using the renewal as leverage for better terms or a managed transition to an alternative provider.

The role of independent oversight

One of the most significant challenges in SME supplier management is that the business often lacks the technical knowledge to evaluate whether the service it is receiving is good. If the MSP says the reason tickets are taking longer to resolve is because of a platform migration, the client typically has no way to challenge that.

Independent oversight, whether from a fractional IT director or an advisory relationship, changes this dynamic. An experienced IT professional who is not commercially aligned with the supplier can assess performance honestly, ask the right questions, and hold the supplier to account in terms they cannot easily deflect. This is not about being difficult. It is about having the informed, senior presence in the client organisation that good suppliers actually respect, and that poor suppliers cannot hide from.

Technology spend is one of the fastest-growing cost lines in most businesses. Cloud services, SaaS tools, managed IT contracts, connectivity, security software – the monthly outgoings add up quickly, and in most SMEs, nobody is looking at the full picture with fresh eyes.

The result is predictable: waste accumulates quietly, renewals happen automatically, and the gap between what you are paying for and what you are actually using widens year by year.

Where the waste typically hides

In my experience working with UK SMEs, the most common sources of IT overspend fall into a handful of categories:

**Unused licences** – Microsoft 365, Salesforce, Adobe and similar tools are typically licensed per user. Leavers whose accounts were never deactivated. Contractors who had temporary access. Seasonal staff. These licences continue to bill monthly long after the person has gone.

**Auto-renewed contracts** – IT contracts, particularly for connectivity, telephony and security software, are typically structured with automatic renewal clauses. Miss the notice window – usually 30 to 90 days before expiry – and you are committed to another term at the current rate, regardless of whether the market has moved.

**Duplicate tooling** – businesses accumulate software over time. A backup solution purchased three years ago still billing alongside the backup included in the MSP contract. Two project management tools doing the same job. Security software from a previous supplier never properly decommissioned.

**Legacy infrastructure** – cloud services provisioned for a headcount or workload that no longer exists. A server specification sized for 60 users when you now have 35. Storage allocations that were never reviewed after a restructure.

**Poorly scoped MSP contracts** – managed service agreements often include a fixed scope of services that no longer reflects how the business operates. You may be paying for on-site support you never use, or for a monitoring service that covers systems you have migrated away from.

The challenge of visibility

The reason these costs persist is not negligence – it is a visibility problem. IT spend in most SMEs is spread across multiple invoices, multiple suppliers, multiple cost centres. Nobody has a single consolidated view of what is being spent, what it is for, and whether it is delivering value.

Finance sees the invoices but not the technical context. The IT supplier sees the technical context but has no particular incentive to flag that you are paying for things you no longer need. The MD approves budgets but does not have time to interrogate line items.

The result is that IT costs tend to drift upward year on year, with no systematic review.

How a vendor rationalisation exercise works

A structured review of IT spend and vendor relationships typically involves four stages:

*1. Audit** – building a complete inventory of all IT suppliers, contracts, licences and services, with associated costs. This is often more time-consuming than expected, because the information exists in multiple places and nobody has assembled it in one view.

**2. Analysis** – mapping actual usage against contracted entitlements. Which licences are actively used? Which services are being consumed? Which contracts are approaching renewal?

**3. Rationalisation** – identifying and eliminating waste. Deactivating unused licences, consolidating duplicate tools, exiting or renegotiating contracts that no longer represent value.

**4. Governance** – putting in place a process to prevent the same waste accumulating again. This typically involves a regular IT spend review, a contract renewal calendar, and clear ownership of vendor relationships.

What a review typically finds

In a business of 20 to 80 people, a thorough vendor rationalisation exercise typically identifies savings of between 10 and 20 percent of total IT spend. In pound terms, for a business spending £5,000 per month on technology, that is £500 to £1,000 per month – £6,000 to £12,000 per year.

More importantly, it creates clarity. The business knows what it is paying for, why, and whether it is getting value. That clarity makes every future technology decision easier and better informed.

The contract renewal opportunity

One of the most consistent findings in vendor reviews is contracts that have auto-renewed at rates significantly above current market. Connectivity and telephony in particular have seen substantial price reductions over recent years – businesses that have not renegotiated are often paying 30 to 40 percent more than equivalent services cost today.

Approaching renewal properly – with independent advice, market comparisons and a clear brief – typically produces better commercial terms than allowing auto-renewal or accepting the supplier’s standard renewal offer.

IT governance is one of those phrases that sounds corporate and abstract until the moment it becomes very real. A supplier goes offline and nobody knows who the contract is with. A key employee leaves and takes their access credentials with them. A cyber insurer declines a claim because there was no documented security policy. A client audit reveals your data handling practices don’t meet their requirements.

These are governance failures. And they happen to small businesses every day.

What IT governance actually means

IT governance is simply the set of policies, processes and oversight mechanisms that ensure your IT systems and technology investments are aligned with your business objectives, managed responsibly, and operating within acceptable risk parameters.

For a large enterprise, that might mean a formal IT governance framework, a dedicated CIO, and quarterly board-level reporting. For a 30-person professional services firm, it means something more proportionate – but the principles are identical.

Good IT governance for an SME covers:

– **Strategic alignment** – are your technology investments actually supporting what the business is trying to do?

– **Risk management** – do you understand the operational and cyber risks associated with your IT systems?

– **Supplier oversight** – are your IT suppliers performing to the standard your contracts require?

– **Compliance** – are you meeting your legal and regulatory obligations around data, security and continuity?

– **Value** – are you getting appropriate return on your IT spend?

Why most SMEs have a governance gap

The honest answer is structural. In most businesses below 50 or 100 people, there is no single person with both the technical understanding to evaluate IT decisions and the seniority to challenge suppliers, set policy and report to the board.

The MD is focused on the business. The Finance Director trusts that IT costs are reasonable. The Office Manager coordinates with the MSP on day-to-day issues. And the MSP – however capable – is not paid to govern. They are paid to keep things running.

The result is a gap between IT delivery and IT leadership. Nobody is asking whether the technology strategy is right. Nobody is challenging the supplier contract at renewal. Nobody is reporting cyber risk to the board in terms the board can act on.

This gap is invisible until it becomes a problem.

The signs that your IT governance needs attention

You may have a governance gap if:

– You are not sure exactly what IT systems and licences your business is paying for

– Your MSP contract has not been reviewed in more than two years

– You have no documented IT security policy

– Leavers’ system access is not removed consistently and promptly

– You have never tested your backup and recovery process

– Your board has no visibility of IT or cyber risk beyond “it’s being handled”

– You don’t know which systems contain personal data or how it is protected

None of these is a crisis in isolation. Collectively, they represent significant operational and commercial exposure.

How right IT governance looks like for an SME

Good governance does not require a large investment or a complex framework. For most SMEs, it means:

**Clear ownership** – someone is responsible for IT and cyber oversight at a senior level. In a small business, this is often best handled fractionally – a part-time IT director who attends board meetings, reviews suppliers and reports on risk, without the cost of a full-time hire.

**Basic documentation** – an IT security policy, an acceptable use policy, and a data register. These do not need to be lengthy documents. They need to exist, be accurate, and be reviewed annually.

**Supplier accountability** – regular service reviews with your MSP, performance metrics that are actually tracked, and contracts that are reviewed before automatic renewal.

**Risk visibility** – the board receives a brief, plain-English update on IT and cyber risk at least quarterly. They understand what the key risks are and what is being done about them.

**Incident readiness** – there is a basic plan for what happens if something goes wrong. Who do you call? What do you communicate to clients? What are the regulatory obligations?

The commercial case for better governance

IT governance is not a compliance exercise. It is a commercial discipline. Businesses with good IT governance:

– Spend less on technology, because spend is reviewed and challenged

– Recover faster from incidents, because plans exist

– Win more contracts, because they can demonstrate security and compliance

– Pay lower cyber insurance premiums, because their risk profile is better

– Attract better talent, because their systems and processes work properly

For a business of 20 to 100 people, the return on investment in proper IT governance is typically significant and measurable within twelve months.

© 2026 Northstar IT & Cyber Advisory Limited. Company registered in England & Wales. Company No. 17038464. About What We Do How We Help Insights FAQs Free Cyber Risk Guide Free Checklist Free AI Risk Guide Privacy PolicyCookie PolicyTerms & ConditionsAccessibility
Fractional IT & Cyber Leadership for UK SMBs & SMEs
Locations: London Kent Essex Sussex Surrey South East